THE DATING OF DAGGERS OF THE POSMU§ TYPE AND THEIR CAUCASIAN ANALOGIES
Table of contents
Share
QR
Metrics
THE DATING OF DAGGERS OF THE POSMU§ TYPE AND THEIR CAUCASIAN ANALOGIES
Annotation
PII
S0869-60630000392-4-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Edition
Pages
84-101
Abstract
The paper is devoted to the acenaces of the Posmuş type from the Early Iron Age sites of the Ciumbrud group. The daggers can be considered as the earliest samples of the bladed weapon of so called Scythian type in the Middle and Southern-Eastern Europe. At present these particular finds are the one of the main cases for dating of the earliest burials of the Ciumbrud group back to the end of the 8th - the first half of the 7th cc. Thus it is necessary to consider in depth not only the dating of their Caucasian and other Eastern parallels but also accompanying grave goods in Transilvania. In the authors' opinion, neither Caucasian and North Black Sea region analogues with their quite wide dating nor grave goods from the burials of the Ciumbrud group provide solid grounds to place the daggers of the Posmuş type to the first half of the 7th c. BC. Combination of bladed weapon with the weapon of long-range combat and also usually spears is common for the burials of the Ciumbrud group with daggers. Vice versa in the Tli cemetery in Osetia the finds of daggers with battle axes and almost complete absence of arrow heads are common.
Keywords
Daggers, the Ciumburd group, the Vekerzugskaya culture, Eastern Carpatian region, Black Sea region, Caucasus, chronology, social stratification
Date of publication
01.07.2016
Number of purchasers
1
Views
627
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

Abramishvili R.M. K voprosu o datirovke pamyatnikov ehpokhi pozdnej bronzy i shirokogo osvoeniya zheleza, obnaruzhennykh na Samtavrskom mogil'nike//VGMG. Tbilisi, 1957. T Kh1Kh-A -Kh1Kh-V. S. 100-144 (na gruz. yaz.).

Abramishvili R.M. K voprosu ob osvoenii zheleza na territorii Vostochnoj Gruzii//VGMG. Tbilisi, 1961. T KhKh11-V. S. 291-382 (na gruz. yaz.).           

Bandrivskij M.S. Kurgany v Shvajkovtsakh i Kotsyubinchikakh -novyj istochnik dlya datirovki Zapadno-podol'skoj gruppy ranneskifskoj kul'tury (po materialam raskopok 2007-2009 gg.)//RAE. № 3. SPb.: Univ. izd. konsortsium, 2013. S. 341-361.

Bandrivs'kij M. Novij ritual'nij ob'єkt chasiv skifs'koï arkhaïki zi Shvajkivets' bilya Chortkova na Ternopil'schini (poperednє povidomlennya)//Vzaєmozv'yazki kul'tur epokh bronzi i rann'ogo zaliza na territoriï Tsentral'noï ta Skhidnoï

Evropi: zbirka naukovikh prats' na poshanu Larisi Ivanivni Krushel'nits'koï. Kiïv; L'viv: IA NANU, 2009. S. 202-235.             

Voroshilov A.N. Akinaki kelermesskogo tipa v donskoj lesostepi//Vostochnoevropejskie drevnosti skifskoj ehpokhi/Red. V.D. Berezutskij i dr. Voronezh: Nauch. kniga, 2011 (Vestnik Ostrogozhskogo istoriko-khudozhestvennogo muzeya im. I. N. Kramskogo; vyp. 1). S. 156-168.   

Voroshilov A.N. Bimetallicheskie mechi skifskogo vremeni iz mezhdurech'ya Dona i Volgi//RA. 2007. № 3. S. 150-156.   

Voroshilov A.N. O serii akinakov kelermesskogo tipa//Drevnost': istoricheskoe znanie i spetsifika istochnika: materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii, posvyaschennoj pamyati Eh.A. Grantovskogo i D.S. Raevskogo). Vyp. IV: 14-16 dekabrya 2009 g. M.: IV RAN, 2009. S. 40-42.              

Esayan S.A., Pogrebova M.N. Skifskie pamyatniki Zakavkaz'ya. M.: Nauka, 1985. 150 s.

Ivanchik A.I. Kimmerijtsy i skify. Kul'turno-istoricheskie i khronologicheskie problemy arkheologii vostochnoevropejskikh stepej i Kavkaza pred-i ranneskifskogo vremeni. M.: Paleograf, 2001 (Stepnye narody Evrazii; t. II). 324 s.   

Ismagilov B.A. Mech skifskogo tipa: istoki proiskhozhdeniya//Skifo-sibirskoe kul'turno-istoricheskoe edinstvo: materialy I Vsesoyuznoj arkheologicheskoj konferentsii (dekabr' 1979 g.)/Otv. red. A.I. Martynov. Kemerovo: Kemerovskij gos. un-t, 1980. S. 8595.         

Kovpanenko G.T., Bessonova S.M., Skoryj S.A. Novye pogrebeniya rannego zheleznogo veka v Poros'e//Drevnosti skifov: sbornik nauchnykh trudov/Red. E.V. Chernenko. Kiev: Izd-vo Instituta arkheologii AN Ukrainy, 1994. S. 41-63.  

Kozubova A., Skakov A.Yu. K voprosu o datirovke akinakov tipa Posmuş na osnovanii kavkazskikh parallelej//Novejshie otkrytiya v arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza: issledovaniya i interpretatsii. XXVII Krupnovskie chteniya: materialy

Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii (Makhachkala, 23-28 aprelya 2012 g.)/Red. M.S. Gadzhiev. Makhachkala: Mavraev', 2012. S. 198-200.   

Leskov A.M. Kimmerijskie mechi i kinzhaly i proiskhozhdenie skifskogo akinaka//Iskusstvo i arkheologiya Irana i ego svyaz' s iskusstvom narodov SSSR s drevnejshikh vremen: tezisy dokladov III Vsesoyuznoj konferentsii. M.: Sov. khudozhnik, 1979. S. 47-49.        

Makalatiya S.I. Raskopki Dvanskogo mogil'nika//SA. 1949. XI. S. 225-240.

Makhortykh S.V. Skify na Severnom Kavkaze. Kiev: Nauk. dumka,1991. 136 s.

Melyukova A.I. Vooruzhenie skifov. M.: Nauka, 1964. 118 s.   

Mikeladze T.K. Kolkhidskie mogil'niki ehpokhi rannego zheleza. Urekskij i Nigvzianskij mogil'niki. Tbilisi: Metsniereba, 1985. 133 s. (na gruz. yaz.)

Novichikhin A.M. Bimetallicheskij kinzhal iz kh. Buzhor Anapskogo rajona//Traditsii i innovatsii v material'noj kul'ture drevnikh obschestv: doklady Vsesoyuznoj konferentsii molodykh uchenykh (Moskva, 20-30 aprelya 1990 g.). M.:

Moskovskij arkheologicheskij informatsionnyj tsentr, 1990. S. 61-73.

Novichikhin A.M. Naselenie Zapadnogo Zakuban'ya v pervoj polovine I tysyacheletiya do n.eh. (po materialam pogrebal'nykh pamyatnikov). Anapa: RIO SGUTiKD, 2006. 220 s.   

Skakov A.Yu. K voprosu ob ehvolyutsii dekora kobano-kolkhidskikh bronzovykh toporov//Drevnosti Evrazii/Otv. red.: S.V. Demidenko, D.V. Zhuravlev. M., 1997. S. 70-87.   

Tekhov B.V. Skify i Tsentral'nyj Kavkaz v VII-VI vv. do n.eh. (Po materialam Tlijskogo mogil'nika). M.: Nauka, 1980. 93 s.

Tekhov B.V. Tajny drevnikh pogrebenij: Arkheologiya, istoriya, ehtnografiya. Vladikavkaz: Proekt-Press, 2002. 544 s.

Topal D.A. Akinaki na zapadnykh rubezhakh Skifii. Nakhodki skifskikh mechej i kinzhalov na territorii Respubliki Moldova//Tyregetia. Arheologie. Istorie Anticä. Serie nouä. Chisinau, 2014. V. VIII , nr. 1. C. 7-43.

Topal D.A. Skifskie akinaki: funktsional'noe razdelenie i kontekst obnaruzheniya//Antropologicheskie issledovaniya v Moldovy: materialy I nauchnoj konferentsii molodykh prepodavatelej i studentov (2627 noyabrya 2004 g.)/Red. A.N. Bulava . Kishinev: Vysshaya antropologicheskaya shkola, 2005. S. 19-32.

Topal D.A., Bruyako I.V. Nakhodki klinkovogo oruzhiya rannikh kochevnikov iz Orgeevskogo rajona (Respublika Moldava)//“Ehllinstvo i iranstvo”. SPb.; Kishinev; Odessa; Bukharest: Vyssh. antropol. shk., 2012 (Stratum plus; № 3/2012). S. 133-144.

Chernenko E.V. Drevnejshie skifskie paradnye mechi (Mel'gunov i Kelermess)//Skifiya i Kavkaz: sb. nauch. tr./Otv. red. A.I. Terenozhkin i dr. Kiev: Nauk. dumka, 1980. S. 7-30.

Chernenko E.V. Persidskie akinaki i skifskie mechi//Iskusstvo i arkheologiya Irana i ego svyaz' s iskusstvom narodov SSSR s drevnejshikh vremen: tezisy dokladov III Vsesoyuznoj konferentsii. M.: Sovetskij khudozhnik, 1979. S. 90-91.

Shishlov A.V., Fedorenko N.V. Pogrebal'nyj obryad plemen Severo-Zapadnogo poberezh'ya Kavkaza v kontse VII -V vv. do n.eh. (po materialam Vladimirovskogo mogil'nika)//Argonavt. Chernomorskij istoricheskij zhurnal. Novorossijsk, 2006. Maj-avgust. № 2 (3). S. 63-73.

Shishlov A.V., Fedorenko N.V., Kolpakova A.V., Kononenko A.P. Material'naya kul'tura Vladimirovskogo mogil'nika//Istoricheskie zapiski. Issledovaniya i materialy. Vyp. 5. Novorossijsk: Novorossijskij gos. ist. muzej-zapovednik, 2007. S. 4-19.

Shramko B.A. Iz istorii skifskogo vooruzheniya//Vooruzhenie skifov i sarmatov/Otv. red. E.V. Chernenko. Kiev: Nauk. dumka, 1984. S. 22-38.

Benadik B. Mana. Keltisches Gräberfeld: Fundkatalog. Nitra: Slowakische Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1983. 167 S.

Boroffka N. Mormäntul hallstattian de la Bato§, Jud. Mure§//Angustia. Sfintu Gheorghe, 2002. № 7. Arheologie. P. 233-240.

Buzdugan C. Pumnale hallstattiene tirzii po teritoriul Romäniei//Cercetäri Arheologice. Bucure§ti, 1976. № 2. P. 239-273.

Chochorowski J. Die Vekerzug-Kultur und ihre östliche Beziehungen//Das Karpatenbecken und die osteuropäische Steppe. München: Südosteuropa Gesellschaft, 1998 (PAS; Bd. 12). S. 473-491.

Chochorowski J. Ekspansja kimmeryjska na tereny Evropy Srodkowej. Krakow: UJ, 1993. 327 s.

Dusek M., Dusek S. Smolenice-Molpir. Befestigter Fürstensitz der Hallstattzeit. II. Nitra: AU SAV, 1995. 203 S.

Fiala F. Das Flachgräberfeld und die prähistorische Ansiedlung von Sanski most//WMBH. 1899. № 6. S. 62-128.

Gawlik A. Zur Genese der skythischen Dolche vom Posmus-Typ aus Siebenbürgen//AAC. 1997-1998. № 34. S. 25-37.

Gumä M. Civilizalia primei epoci a fierului in sud-vestul Romäniei. Bucure§ti: Institutul Roman de Tracologie, 1993. 311 p.           

Hellmuth A. Pfeilspitzen. Untersuchungen zu den sogenannten skythischen Pfeilspitzen aus der befestigten Höhensiedlung von Smolenice-Molpir. Bonn: Habelt, 2006 (UPA; Bd. 128). 300 S.

Ivantchik A. I. Das Problem der ethnischen Zugehörigkeit der Kimmerier und die kimmerische archäologische Kultur//PZ. 1997. Vol. 72, № 1. S. 12-53.   

Kemenczei T. Die Schwerter in Ungarn II: Vollgriffschwerter. Stuttgart: Steiner, 1991 (PBF; Bd IV/9). 191 S.

Kemenczei T. Studien zu den Denkmälern skythisch geprägter Alföld-Gruppe. Budapest: Magyar Nemzeti Müzeum, 2009. 410 S.

Kossack G. Tli Grab 85. Bemerkungen zum Beginn des skythenzeitlichen Formenkreis im Kaukasus//BAVA. 1983. № 5. S. 89-186.

Kossack G. Von den Anfängen des skytho-iranischen Tierstils//Skythika. Vorträge zur Entstehung des skytho-iranischen Tierstils und zu Denkmälern des Bosporanischen Reichs anlässlich einer Ausstellung der Leningrader Ermitage in München 1984. München: Verlag der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1987. S. 24-86.           

Kozubova A. Hroby so zeleznymi sekerkami na pohrebi-skäch zo starsej doby zeleznej v karpatsko-dunajskom priestore//ZSNM. 2010. CIV. Archeologia. № 20. S. 45-65.

Kozubova A. Pohrebiska vekerzugskej kultury v Chotine na juhozapadnom Slovensku. Vfhodnotenie. Bratislava: Vydavatel'stvo Univerzity Komenskeho v Bratislave, 2013. 454 s.

Marinescu G. Die jüngere Hallstattzeit in Nordostsiebenbürgen//Dacia N. S. Bucure§ti, 1984. V. 28. № 1, 2. S. 47-83.

Metzner-Nebelsick C. Der „Thrako-Kimmerische“ Formenkreis aus der Sicht der Urnenfelder-und Hallstattzeit im südöstlichen Pannonien. Teil 1: Text. Rahden/Westf.: Leidorf, 2002 (Vorgeschichtliche Forschungen; Bd. 23). 542 S.

Parducz M. Graves from The Scythian Age at Artand (County Hajdu-Bihar)//AAASH. 1965. № 17. P. 137-231.

Parzinger H., Stegmann-Rajtar S. Smolenice-Molpir und der Beginn skythischer Sachkultur in der Slowakei//PZ. 1988. V 63. № 2. S. 162-178.

Pirtskhalava M. Monuments of Scythian Culture in Georgia//AA.1995. № 1. P. 53-62.

Pirtskhalava M. On the Dating of Some Burials with the Inventory of Scythian Type from Georgia//Essays on the Archaeology of Colchis in the Classical Period: Dedicated to the 70th Birth Annivewrsary of Prof. Otar Lordkipanidze.

Dziebani (J. Centre for Archaeol. Stud. Georgian Acad. Sci., Supplement IV). Tbilisi, 2001. S. 77-86 (Georgian language).

Stibbe C. M. Eine Bronzehydria mit menschlichen Protomen//Bull. Mus. Hongr. Beaux-Arts. 2004. № 101. S. 31-55, 145-158.

Topal D. Akinakai of Kelermes Type: New Discoveries in Central Bessarabia//Marisia. 2014. № XXIII. P. 13-32.    

Trachsel M. Are there “Cimmerian” and “Scythian” finds in Switzerland? The absolute dating of the early Iron Age between the Apls and the Altai region. A reconsideration//Archaeology of the Bronze and Iron Age: Proceedings of the International Archaeological Conference in Szazhalombatta, 3-7 Oct. 1996.         

Budapest: Archaeolingua Alapitvany, 1999. P. 187-205. Vasiliev V Un nou mormînt scitic descoperit la Batoç // AMN. 1966. № 3. P. 411-420. 

Vasiliev V., Badea A., Man I. Douä nol morminte scitice de-scoperite la Teiuç//Sargetia. 1973. № 10. P. 27-43.

Vulpe A. Descoperile hallstattiene din zona Auidului//Thra-co-Dacica. Bucureçti, 1984. № 36. P. 36-63.

Vulpe A. Die Kurzschwerter, Dolche und Streitmesser der Hallstattzeit in Rumänien. München: Beck, 1990 (PBF; Bd. VI/9). 208 S.

Werner W. M. Eisenzeitliche Trensen an der unteren und mittleren Donau. München: Beck, 1988 (PBF; Bd. XVI/9). 229 S.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate